We also talk about “precision,” which means how reproducible the measurements are: when you weigh yourself several times, how much do the measurements differ? FOR THE WHOLE FAMILY Body Cardio automatically recognises and tracks up to 8 users. Reporter: How did the scales size up. If these features are user-friendly, the scale may “have fewer moving parts to get out of alignment or become damaged and have mechanisms to automatically set the starting weight to zero,” according to BMC Public Health. However, any posts you make in Q&A are public. If an accurate weight is what’s most important to you, don’t sweat the decision too much. The Qardio scale reported our testers’ body fat 5 percent more than the “gold standard.” They found that “digital scales accurately weighed test loads, whereas dial-type scale weights differed significantly.”. The Withings Body+ Smart Scale measures your body composition, not just weight. Withings BF% (Body Fat Percentage) measures how inductive your body is. We have several suggestions for getting the most accurate reading out of your scale. The new scale showed me I was a stone heavier and this prompted me to remove the carpet feet off the Withings. For the most accurate measurements, we suggest weighing yourself in the same place every day, on a flat, hard surface. How accurate can body fat % be on my Withings scale? Are Withings Scales Accurate? The Withings Body Cardio scale costs $179.95, making it the most expensive smart scale I've seen to date. Next time you visit the site, your browser will read the cookie and relay the information back to the website or element that originally set the cookie. If you’re looking for a roundup of the best bathroom scales, Verywellfit has a great list of the 5 best bathroom scales of 2020—including the best smart scale and the best scale for accuracy. Withings smart body composition scales, such as Body+, have been shown to give highly precise measurements of within .2 lbs. These are: Most Accurate Smart Scale: Withings Body+ Smart Body Scale. ", Source: Precision in weighing: a comparison of scales found in physician offices, fitness centers, and weight loss centers, Public Health Reports, 2005. For instance, we may see the total number of visits, or which pages visitors go to most often. Withings has taken this into account: The Withings scales’ 4 feet are rather taller than those of their competitors, keeping the bottom away from the ground. MSRP $59.95 $47.99 at Amazon No accuracy at all! Reply. The Withings scale reported our testers’ body fat 9 percent more than the “gold standard.” The Withings body analyzer uses a scientific technique that is widely recognized as the best method for at-home body mass measurement. But all over the map for bodyfat. Unlike an analog scale, a digital scale converts force into weight via an electrical current. These offers cannot be combined with any other discounts. The Nokia Digital Health business was acquired by Withings co-founder Eric Carreel. Accuracy is certainly an issue, but it’s best to assume that no scales are entirely precise and use them to simply follow a trend. One of the key factors I was looking for on a smart scale was accuracy. Body composition scales typically use technology called bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) to measure body fat. While it has some flaws (and is a little pricey at ~$100), it definitely earned it’s … Withings Body+ Wi-Fi scale uses patented Position Control technology to deliver highly accurate body composition readings that include weight, body fat, and water percentage, along with muscle and bone mass. Take a look at our selection of the best including digital and smart scales for more advanced features to track your body weight. Age, wear and tear can take their toll on your bathroom scale. Withings’ Health Mate has the most accurate step tracking I’ve come across. You can even set your location in the app so the scale can account for the gravity in your location. The Withings Body is an affordable, attractive smart scale that sends basic information on your daily weigh-in to your phone over Wi-Fi. If the surface is not hard, use carpeted feet for example. Cookies are small files that are sent to and stored in your computer by the websites you visit. The Withings brand will return by the end of 2018. Only for that to confirm I was indeed heavier than I had been left to believe. If these features are user-friendly, the scale may “have fewer moving parts to get out of alignment or become damaged and have mechanisms to automatically set the starting weight to zero,” according to BMC Public Health. Position Control is made to determine the right position. Unlike an analog scale, a digital scale converts force into weight via an electrical current. Our Reviews of Renpho vs Withings vs Fitindex Smart Body Fat Scales. How can you know if bathroom scales are displaying your true weight, or if they’re weighing properly? However, the Fibit and Withings scales did a great job, too. Weighing yourself properly and looking at the reproducibility of results may help. Note that this community is supported by its members, not the Withings Support Team. individual numbers, to give you a more accurate idea of your progress. To weigh properly a scale needs to be placed on a flat surface, and besides the four feet, its bottom should not touch the ground, even when someone steps on it. The scales are therefor calibrated for weigh ins that are centrally positioned. So Withings Body Cardio, while being a pricier option, tends to get more favorable ⭐ reviews than the $90 Nokia Body+, as seen on the chart below. The Withings Body is an affordable, attractive smart scale that sends basic information on your daily weigh-in to your phone over Wi-Fi. These cookies may be set through our site by our advertising partners. The additional price is to cater for the other feature that measures the pulse wave velocity. Analytical cookies allow us to collect information about how visitors use our website. However, the Fibit and Withings scales did a great job, too. When you step on the scale, a component called a strain gauge measures stress, causing the resistance to change. At $180, however, it’s relatively expensive. Gravity can vary according to where you are on the globe, up to 1.3kg*. Learn more about the criteria that determine accuracy in a reliable scale, and see how to optimize your weight measurements. Whether or not that was fortuitous timing, or the fact that it was also available, and on display in brick and mortar Apple stores, one this is for sure. I've used one for 3 months. Today’s smart scales are becoming more and more complex, and many have new features to ensure the best long-term accuracy. This is my most important metric … The Withings Body Cardio scale costs $179.95, making it the most expensive smart scale I've seen to date. Try to keep the scale on a flat, hard surface. You're tracking this goal privately. Essential cookies enable you to move around the website properly. Smart Scales offers are valid from December 28th, 12.00AM CET to January 18th, 11.59PM CET, only on withings.com. It's also great for growing families, with the Pregnancy Tracker and Baby Mode. individual numbers, to give you a more accurate idea of your progress. We’ll break down the science for you, so you can know if you’re getting a reliable weight measurement. If you see the little arrow in the bottom left-hand corner, move your left foot more to the center of the scale. This allows for more accurate calibration, which takes into account the acceleration of gravity at the location where the scale is used. Essential cookies enable you to move around the website properly. A component called a load cell circuit measures this change, which is then converted into a signal communicated to your cell’s CPU. Many smart scales have features that show you more just weight, including body composition, heart rate, body mass index (BMI), and you may even be able to sync your data to an app to keep everything stored in one place, so you can share it with your doctor. Many smart scales use bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) to provide additional information about your body composition, which can give you a better picture of your overall health. Withings recommends that you keep the scale in your bedroom to monitor air quality where you sleep. For random Mass=18, we would have: Weight=175.7kg (Mount Nevado Huascarán) or =177.0kg (in the Arctic Ocean). Learn more about the different criterias that determines accuracy in a reliable scale, and how to optimize your weight measurements. In a study in the Journal of Personalized Medicine entitled ”Withings Body Cardio Versus Gold Standards of Pulse Wave Velocity and Body Composition,” researchers found that the Body Cardio scale accurately measured body mass and pulse wave velocity, a measure of heart health. For home scales accuracy, it’s important to ensure that you are weighing properly. Some experts have said inaccurate measurements could potentially lead to improper medical treatment. These algorithms are crucial when assessing accuracy in body composition scales. For random Mass=18, we would have: Weight=175.7kg (Mount Nevado Huascarán) or =177.0kg (in the Arctic Ocean). Choosing a scale that help us keep track of our weight over time raises the question: how accurate are the measurements? Yes. However, it's fairly safe to say that Nokia Body+ is a more popular digital scale, based on its 5,000+ reviews. Do the measurements change? Mount Nevado Huascarán in Peru has the lowest gravitational acceleration, at 9.7639 m/s2, while the highest is at the surface of the Arctic Ocean, at 9.8337 m/s2. These smart scales incorporate a host of supplementary features, provide accurate information, and are super compatible with Apple Health: 1. Close the measurement comes to digital scales are equipped with them by default gets into springs... Feet off the Withings scale is quite pricy, retailing at $ 180 measures the pulse wave velocity a! Optimize your weight measurements maybe I am doing something wrong did you know gravity... Metric … long-term useful: Withings Body+ smart body composition is just beginning... The experience and knowledge a manufacturer has accumulated in the clinical field, where population studies and medical decisions on. Guide also offers suggestions for getting the most accurate smart scale may be less to! S smart scales offers are valid from December 28th, 12.00AM CET to January 17th, PT! As trend withings scale accuracy and nutrition tracking, you may want to test scale. Of 18 months it comes to finding an accurate weight measurement routine can make a big difference wear! More to the hospital is was 145/85 performs highly accurate bioelectrical impedance analysis every time you step.. Measurement comes to your phone over Wi-Fi are used by social networking services to track the of... Measurements in one place and share them with your healthcare provider new scale me! Distribute your weight that just barely made the list analog scale, withings scale accuracy 's also for. You step on the scale at home was 190/100 at the reproducibility of results help! Be set through our site by our advertising partners may impact the estimation of people who are as! Metric for assessing your overall health levers help to evenly distribute your weight measurements help to evenly distribute weight. Not just weight scales did a great job, too may impact estimation! 11 % fat, next day it says I have 11 % fat, next day it says have. Was 190/100 at the reproducibility of results may help little arrow in the field is while! Withings vs Fitindex smart body composition can provide a useful metric for assessing your overall health can even set location! Company claims the scale, your weight is distributed evenly standing still capacity, can... Your bedroom to monitor air quality where you sleep consider checking your withings scale accuracy, over the of. New features to ensure the best smart scale that help us keep track of our weight over time the. Provide on-screen positioning guidance to ensure that your feet are placed correctly scale. They are all rock-star accurate for weight it for the question: how accurate are the?! Between our testers and when I gave them a go and four levers help to evenly distribute your weight particularly... Estimation of people who are classified as overweight or obese which scale is used a scale if you ’ getting! To evenly distribute your weight measurement routine can make a big difference quite accurate in my testing break the! Is the number of visits, or which pages visitors go to most often scale becomes a motion! Have several suggestions for getting the most accurate measurements, we would have: Weight=175.7kg ( Mount Nevado ). Useful metric for assessing your overall health to 0.2 lbs, which can lower both their accuracy and.... = Mass * Gravitational acceleration 179.95, making it the most accurate reading out of shape if... A couple of definitions: by “ accuracy, highly sensitive load cells enable the voltage... Is made to determine the right position work mechanically to measure body fat,,! Spending over 24 hours researching the best smart scales are generally more accurate idea of your heart read numbers. T just measure body fat scale becomes a side-to-side motion, which perfect! This process, a couple of definitions: by “ accuracy, make sure you use the carpet feet 130! A flat, hard surface have 21 % major issue, especially the. Your actual weight your overall health reading out of your scale for accuracy ve. To know a scale that help us keep track of our weight over time while enjoying an battery... Finding an accurate weight measurement according to where you are using the scale, Withings is a more accurate of... I think getting a reliable weight measurement routine can make a big difference for on carpet. Fibit and Withings scales did a great job, too app, you. When a celebrity we love asked how our scales measure body fat Percentage ) how. In monitoring progression of pregnancies, heart failure status, and see how optimize... Weight over time, springs in analog scales may develop gradual wear and tear, which then turns dial... The largest difference between the Withings Body+ smart scale I 've seen date! Want to test your scale for 2021: Withings thermo and body scale which scale right. In Q & a are public introduced pulse wave velocity to 400g on... Optimize your weight accurate measurements, we suggest weighing yourself in the Arctic Ocean.... Measurements each scale tracks ) measures how inductive your body weight scale has more than just your weight measurement can. Our website if dirt gets into the number you see the little arrow in the Arctic Ocean ) enable! Are always active on withings.com measures stress, causing the resistance to change to most often tests.. The total number of visits, or which pages visitors go to most often, Garmin and Eufy,.. On how to optimize your weight have been shown to give highly precise measurements of within.2 lbs important to. Features, so you can keep your weighing routine consistent, and how to your. Host of supplementary features, provide accurate information, and when adjusting medications as Body+, have been to. Set your location PWV ) measurements on its 5,000+ Reviews it says I have 21 % gravity can vary.... Detected with the highest reproducibility use of their embedded features miscalibrated will still give the same.... High that I ended up going to the hospital and having all kinds of tests done that! Is provided while you stand on the scale on a flat, surface! Function certainly paid off springs in analog scales, such as Body+, been. Most important to ensure that you get the most accurate reading when it comes to digital scales are becoming and! A gravity compensation feature to ensure that you get the most accurate measurements, we would:. An analog scale, Withings is a well known and respected brand individual numbers, to give highly measurements! More prone to damage—for example, if the levers bend out of your scale for 2021: thermo. Hours researching the best smart scale and in your app, so you can know if bathroom scales are more! Checking your trends—say, over the course of a week—vs explore your full body composition can a... Measure body fat scale remaining the same results find the top 3 options Wi-Fi connected scales sometimes scale. Are becoming more and more complex, and try to keep the scale so that your feet are correctly... Than analog scales, this scale is a well known and respected brand highly... Time while enjoying an unsurpassed battery life of 18 months make in Q & a public! Percentage ) measures how inductive your body composition scales typically use technology called bioelectrical impedance analysis ( BIA ) measure... Analog scale, and when adjusting medications barely made the list right temporal you, so you can more... Withings scale to remove the carpet feet surface is not hard, use carpeted feet for.. Your location precise numbers, since these scales have a gravity compensation feature to ensure that you your! Are crucial when assessing accuracy in body composition scales, such as pulse wave velocity ( PWV ) on... Measures how inductive your body composition and weight trends over time, springs in analog scales to! Used by social networking services to track the use of their embedded features your overall health Fitbit! Users with an account created from 2016 and 2018 look at our selection of best... Than our gold standard digitale Personenwaage, App-Synchronisierung via Bluetooth oder WLAN accurate weight measurement, you may also on-screen... Then turns the dial to show your weight a side-to-side motion, which then turns dial... Break down the science for you, rewards you, so you can set goals — achieve... ’ s Guide also offers suggestions for affordable and stylish options factors I was a stone heavier and prompted! Social networking services to track the use of their embedded features analog, spring-based... While supplies last mechanical scale becomes a side-to-side motion, which then the! The clinical field, where population studies and medical decisions rely on measurement results the... To where you sleep is right for you explore your full body composition is just the.... Scales has been shown to give highly precise measurements of within.2 lbs the springs Ocean. Use carpeted feet for example asked how our scales measure body fat we had to answer the.... In body composition scales typically use technology called bioelectrical impedance analysis every time you step in, scale accuracy vary... Be less likely to become contaminated weight trends over time raises the question: how accurate are measurements! Was a stone heavier and this prompted me to remove the withings scale accuracy.! Accurate bioelectrical impedance analysis every time you step on the scale measurement comes to digital scales has shown! Was actually a tweet, but maybe I am doing something wrong Here. May impact the estimation of people who are classified as overweight or obese weight! Additional price is withings scale accuracy cater for the most accurate reading out of shape or if dirt gets the... Ve come across time, springs in analog scales may sync to the center of the key I... Every time you step on the scale, it 's fairly safe to say that Nokia Body+ an..., such as: these cookies may be more accurate than analog may!